Signal Controversy Highlights Risks of Using Commercial Messaging Apps for Confidential Communications
Photo by Praveen kumar Mathivanan
Signal, the popular encrypted messaging app praised globally for robust user privacy, has come under intense scrutiny following reports that senior U.S. officials allegedly used the platform to discuss sensitive military operations. The story, first reported by The Atlantic on March 24, 2025.
Although this specific case involves high-level government use, it also serves as a critical reminder to businesses regarding the risks of using consumer-grade messaging apps for confidential workplace discussions.
Signal is not a multifunctional 'super-app' focused on social media, payments, or shopping, like, for instance, WeChat, which we previously explored in detail. Instead, Signal is purely focused on secure, private messaging and communication.
Signal, managed by the non-profit Signal Foundation, has long positioned itself as the go-to app for secure, encrypted communication. It offers end-to-end encryption, minimal data collection, and a strong focus on user privacy, which has attracted millions worldwide, particularly journalists, privacy advocates, and businesses.
While Signal is indeed used in workplaces, its adoption tends to be specialized rather than mainstream. It is frequently utilized in journalism, activism, human rights advocacy, and by smaller remote or hybrid teams prioritizing data privacy. However, large enterprises and regulated industries such as finance, healthcare, or defense typically avoid using Signal due to the absence of specific certifications, compliance requirements, and auditing capabilities.
Experts stress that while Signal provides significant security for general use, it lacks official accreditation for handling classified governmental or highly confidential corporate information. Organizations across sectors are now reconsidering their communication protocols, especially in industries where sensitive information is routine.
The recent controversy raises vital questions for employers: How secure is secure enough for professional communications? Should organizations mandate specialized communication platforms with higher security certifications for sensitive internal discussions?
Additionally, businesses using Signal or similar encrypted apps are encouraged to reassess their internal policies, team training, and cybersecurity practices. Clear guidelines defining which types of workplace communications are appropriate for encrypted messaging apps versus accredited secure systems are becoming increasingly critical.
Employers and IT departments alike should take note, ensuring their workforce is educated and equipped to handle sensitive communications responsibly and securely. New Stardom will continue to monitor developments and provide informative content on messaging apps and communication security practices in the workplace.
Have insights on work and the future of work? Submit an opinion piece to New Stardom. Love work and career books? Explore our fun workplace book collection.
New Stardom is an independent magazine covering the Future of Work, AI, and emerging job trends. Stay informed and explore more on New Stardom.
